Evidence Review Part 3: Preparing for Synthesis

15.0 pts

Excellent

Made all corrections from previous reference list and added additional references as appropriate; <2 APA errors..

Satisfactory

Made some corrections from previous reference list; 2 APA errors.

Below Satisfactory

Did not make corrections from previous reference list; >2 APA errors.

35.0 pts

Excellent

Table is fully completed including all “keeper” resources with <3 errors in classification and presentation of information.

Above Satisfactory

Table is fully completed including all “keeper” resources with 3-5 errors in classification and presentation of information.

Satisfactory

Table is partially completed; has 6-10 omissions or errors in classification and presentation of information.

Below Satisfactory

Table is partially completed with > 10 omissions or errors in classification and presentation of information.

Excellent

Table is fully completed with all resources correctly classified.

Above Satisfactory

Table has <2 errors in classification.

Satisfactory

Table has 2 errors in classification.

Below Satisfactory

Table has >2 errors in classification.

Excellent

Table is fully completed and includes all studies that had an intervention correctly identified.

Above Satisfactory

Table includes 85-99% of studies that had an intervention.

15.0 pts

Satisfactory

Table includes 75-85% of studies that had an intervention.

Below Satisfactory

Table includes <75% of studies that had an intervention.

Excellent

Data in table cells are concise, yet clear, not in complete sentences or overly wordy. Legend is provided as needed.

Satisfactory

Data in table cells are somewhat clear OR overly wordy; Legend is provided as needed.

Below Satisfactory

Data are incomplete, difficult to decipher; no Legend provided.